Spooky Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs: 12 Creepy Bites

Oh, Halloween! Seriously, is there anything more fun than throwing a killer party and seeing the delighted (or maybe slightly terrified!) faces of your guests when they see the food? Every year, I get this itch to make everything completely over-the-top, but let’s be real, who has the time? That’s why I’m SO excited to share my absolute favorite trick for a spooky, spectacular spread: the Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs Halloween Recipe! These little guys are just too much fun. I remember making a huge platter of them for my niece’s spooky bash last year, and the kids went absolutely nuts. They’re surprisingly simple, totally no-cook, and wow, do they make a statement. If you’re looking for a guaranteed hit that’s as easy as it is eye-catching, you’ve found it!

Why You’ll Love This Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs Halloween Recipe

Seriously, these little eyeball appetizers are a lifesaver! They’re ridiculously easy to whip up, taking hardly any time at all. Plus, the best part? It’s a total no-cook recipe, which means less fuss and more time for you to actually enjoy your party! They’re also guaranteed to be a showstopper – so spooky and fun! My favorite thing is that they taste just as good as they look, a perfect combo of salty salami and creamy, mild mozzarella that everyone, kids and adults alike, seems to gobble up.

Gather Your Spooky Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs Ingredients

Alright, let’s get down to business and gather everything we need for these creepy-crawly creations. You really don’t need much, which is part of why I love them so much! First up, grab about 12 slices of your favorite salami. The kind that’s not too thin, not too thick––just right for draping! Then, you’ll want 12 of those adorable little fresh mozzarella balls, the bocconcini kind, and you’ll need to halve each one of those. Next are the pupils: 12 pitted black olives, also halved. For those spooky bloodshot veins, we’ll need just a few tiny pieces of red bell pepper. Oh, and have some toothpicks handy; they’re like our little construction tools here!

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs

Alright, let’s get these spooky eyeballs assembled! It’s honestly so easy, you’ll feel like a Halloween magician. This whole Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs Halloween Recipe is completely no-cook, so no need to even turn on the oven. First things first:

Prepare the Mozzarella Base

Grab your halved mozzarella balls and place them cut-side down on your platter or a clean surface. This gives us a nice, stable foundation to build on.

Adding the Salami and Pupil

Now for the eyeball look! Take two slices of salami and gently drape them over the mozzarella, kind of overlapping them a bit. Then, take your halved black olive and pop it right in the middle of the mozzarella to be the spooky pupil. Make sure it’s sitting nicely!

Creating the Spooky Veins

This is where the real creepiness comes in! Take those tiny little pieces of red bell pepper and strategically place them on the mozzarella to look like bloodshot veins. You can gently press them in with a toothpick––it really helps them stick and look super creepy!

Securing and Finishing Your Eyeballs

If your eyeballs are looking a little wobbly, don’t worry! You can pop a toothpick through the bottom part of the mozzarella and salami to keep everything together. And for an extra spooky touch, try adding a tiny sliver of black olive right above the olive pupil to make it look like an eyelid – totally optional but super effective!

Tips for Perfect Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs

Okay, so these eyeballs are pretty forgiving, but a few little tricks can make them even spookier and easier to make! If you can’t find those tiny bocconcini mozzarella balls, don’t fret! You can just slice up a larger ball of fresh mozzarella and cut out little circles with a tiny cookie cutter or even a small glass rim. For the pupils, if you want something a bit different or maybe you’re out of olives, slices of pimento-stuffed olives or even tiny bits of roasted red pepper could work in a pinch! And don’t forget that eyelid trick I mentioned – a little sliver of black olive tucked just above the main pupil really ups the creepy factor, trust me!

Serving and Storing Your Halloween Eyeballs

These spooky little guys are best served chilled! I love arranging them on a dark platter, maybe with some spooky cobwebs I’ve scattered around. They look super creepy peeking out from behind a bowl of punch! You can totally get a head start on these; just assemble them a few hours before your party and keep them covered in the fridge. If any are left over (which is rare!), just pop them back into an airtight container in the fridge. They’re best eaten the next day, but honestly, they’re so addictive you might not have any leftovers anyway!

Frequently Asked Questions about this Halloween Recipe

Got questions about our spooky little eyeballs? I totally get it! When you’re planning a Halloween bash, you want everything to be just right. Let me clear up some of the common things people ask me about these fun Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs!

Can I make the Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs ahead of time?

Absolutely! You can totally prep these a few hours before your party. Just assemble them and keep them covered in the fridge. They hold up really well!

Are there any vegetarian alternatives for the salami?

Good question! While salami is key to the flavor, for a vegetarian twist, you could try using thinly sliced, roasted red pepper strips or even some sun-dried tomatoes. Just make sure they’re pliable enough to drape!

How do I make the veins look more realistic?

To get those super creepy bloodshot veins, use a toothpick to gently press the thin red bell pepper slivers onto the mozzarella. You can even try making them curve around the pupil a bit for a really unsettling look!

Estimated Nutritional Information

Just so you know, these spooky bites are pretty light! Each eyeball serving is estimated to have around 75 calories, with about 6 grams of fat, 4 grams of protein, and just 1 gram of carbs. Remember, this can jump up or down a bit depending on the exact brands of salami and mozzarella you use, but it gives you a good idea!

Dont forget Amazing DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween

For more recipes follow me on PINTEREST

Print