Amazing Buckeye Graham Crackers: 10-12 Min Bake

Oh, I just LOVE taking those classic candy flavors we all grew up with and giving them a little homemade twist! You know, the kind of treats that just scream childhood nostalgia? Well, get ready, because these Buckeye Graham Crackers are exactly that. They’re like your favorite peanut butter and chocolate candy goodness, but wrapped up in a super easy, perfectly crumbly graham cracker package. I’ve been baking these for years, and honestly, they’re just ridiculously good and surprisingly simple to whip up. Trust me, once you try these, you’ll be making them again and again!

Why You’ll Love These Buckeye Graham Crackers

• Super Easy to Make: Seriously, the dough comes together in minutes and no fancy techniques needed!
• That Perfect Flavor Combo: Rich peanut butter meets toasty graham cracker – it’s a match made in heaven!
• Nostalgia Overload: Tastes just like those beloved Buckeye candies, but in a delightful cookie form.
• Crowd-Pleaser Guaranteed: Everyone adores these, making them perfect for parties, bake sales, or just a Tuesday treat.

Ingredients for Buckeye Graham Crackers

Alright, let’s get down to what you’ll need for these yummy Buckeye Graham Crackers. You won’t believe how simple it is! First up, grab 2 cups of all-purpose flour, and then we’ll need 1 cup of graham cracker crumbs. Yes, you read that right, more graham cracker goodness! For sweetness, we’ve got 1/2 cup of granulated sugar, plus 1 teaspoon of baking soda and 1/2 teaspoon of salt to balance it all out. The magic in the dough comes from 1 cup (that’s two sticks!) of unsalted butter, make sure it’s softened, and 1/4 cup of honey for that perfect touch of sweetness and chew. Don’t forget 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract for extra flavor! For the irresistible filling, you’ll need 1 cup of creamy peanut butter and 1/2 cup of powdered sugar. Easy peasy, right?

Equipment Needed for Buckeye Graham Crackers

You really don’t need anything fancy for these cookies! Just grab a large mixing bowl for the dough, and a separate smaller bowl for that yummy peanut butter filling. You’ll want a couple of baking sheets ready to go, lined with parchment paper – I always use parchment, it makes cleanup a breeze! A rolling pin is key to get that perfect 1/4-inch thickness, and of course, you’ll need some fun cookie cutters if you want to get creative with shapes!

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Buckeye Graham Crackers

Alright, let’s get these amazing Buckeye Graham Crackers made! It’s a pretty straightforward process, but paying attention to a few little things really makes a difference. Trust me, the smell that fills your kitchen is just heavenly!

Preparing the Graham Cracker Dough

First things first, get that oven preheated to 350°F (that’s 175°C). While it’s warming up, grab your big mixing bowl and whisk together all your dry ingredients: the flour, graham cracker crumbs, sugar, baking soda, and salt. Make sure they’re really well combined. Then, toss in your softened butter, the honey, and that lovely vanilla. Mix it all up until it forms a nice, cohesive dough. It might seem a bit crumbly at first, but keep at it! Once it looks good, divide the dough in half, wrap each half snugly in plastic wrap, and pop them in the fridge to chill for at least 30 minutes. This makes them so much easier to handle!

Crafting the Peanut Butter Filling

While the dough is doing its chilling thing, let’s whip up that gooey peanut butter center. Just take your creamy peanut butter and the powdered sugar and mix them together in a medium bowl. Stir it until it’s nice and smooth – you want it to be easily spreadable but not too runny. It should be just perfect for filling those cookies!

Assembling Your Buckeye Graham Crackers

Okay, dough is chilled, filling is ready – time to assemble! Lightly flour your work surface, and take out one half of the dough. Roll it out nice and even, about ¼-inch thick. I usually like to cut mine into simple squares or rectangles, but honestly, use whatever cutters you have! Now, grab about a teaspoon of that peanut butter filling and put it on one of your dough shapes. Then, take another dough shape and place it right on top. Gently press the edges to seal everything in, making sure that yummy peanut butter center doesn’t escape. It’s kind of like making little sandwiches! You can even use a fork to crimp the edges if you’re feeling fancy, just like Grandma used to do!

Baking and Cooling Your Buckeye Graham Crackers

Once they’re all assembled, carefully place your Buckeye Graham Crackers onto the baking sheets you prepared earlier. You don’t want them too close together. Now, pop them into that preheated oven for about 10 to 12 minutes. You’re looking for them to be just lightly golden brown around the edges. Keep an eye on them though, because ovens can be a bit wild! When they look perfect, take them out. Let them cool on the baking sheets for just a few minutes – they’ll be super delicate right out of the oven. After that, transfer them over to a wire rack to cool completely. It’s SO hard to wait, but trust me, they’ll be worth it! You’ll find links to my Honey Curry Roasted Cauliflower and Roasted Potatoes with Baked Feta if you need more baking inspiration!

Tips for Perfect Buckeye Graham Crackers

Okay, so you want your Buckeye Graham Crackers to be absolutely perfect, right? You’ve got to try a couple of my favorite tricks! First, when you’re rolling out the dough, if it feels a little sticky, don’t go crazy adding more flour. Just pop it back in the fridge for another 10 minutes – it makes a WORLD of difference. Also, don’t overbake these! Pull them out when they’re just starting to look golden around the edges. I learned that the hard way with my Secretly Healthy Zucchini Brownies; nobody wants a dry cookie! Seriously, it’s like with my Healthy Banana Muffins, a little patience goes a long way. Lastly, making sure your peanut butter filling is really smooth, almost like frosting, helps it stay put and not ooze out during baking. Happy baking!

Ingredient Notes and Substitutions for Buckeye Graham Crackers

So, about these ingredients – a few little things can make a big difference! For the peanut butter, I mean, you can totally use crunchy if you love that texture, but creamy really makes these feel like the classic Buckeye candy. And honey is great for chewiness, but if you don’t have it, you can use agave nectar or even a bit of maple syrup, though it might change the flavor just a tiny bit! If you’re looking for something like keto flourless fudge cookies, you might need to swap out the flour and sugar for almond flour and a keto sweetener, but these original ones are just so darn good!

Storing and Reheating Your Buckeye Graham Crackers

Okay, so you’ve made these amazing Buckeye Graham Crackers, and you want them to stay fresh and delicious, right? My biggest tip is to store them in an airtight container at room temperature. Seriously, they’re so good, they probably won’t last long anyway! I’ve found they stay perfectly chewy and tasty for about 3 to 4 days this way. If you wanted to freeze them, you could, but honestly, I think they’re best enjoyed fresh after they’ve cooled completely!

Frequently Asked Questions about Buckeye Graham Crackers

Got questions about making these yummy Buckeye Graham Crackers? I’ve totally got you covered!

Can I make these gluten-free?

You know, you definitely could try to make them gluten-free! I haven’t personally experimented with it much, but I bet a good 1-to-1 gluten-free baking flour blend would work similarly to the all-purpose flour. You might also need to adjust the liquid slightly, maybe add a tiny bit more honey if the dough feels too dry. If you’re curious about gluten-free living, you might check out some of my gluten-free recipes for inspiration!

How do I prevent the filling from leaking?

The key here is to not use too much filling – just about a teaspoon! Also, make sure to press those edges together really well when you’re sealing the cookies. A little fork crimp on the edges can help create a stronger seal. Oh, and make sure your dough isn’t too warm; the chilled dough is much easier to seal without the filling squishing out.

What’s the best way to cut the dough?

Honestly, I just use a pizza cutter or a sharp knife to cut mine into little squares or rectangles – it’s super fast and easy. If you’re feeling fancy, feel free to use cookie cutters for fun shapes! Just try to keep the pieces relatively uniform in size so they bake evenly.

Can I use different types of peanut butter?

You totally can! While creamy peanut butter gives you that classic Buckeye candy texture, using crunchy peanut butter will add a fun little crunch inside. Just make sure it’s the standard stuff and not a natural peanut butter that’s super oily, as that might make the filling a bit too messy. If you’re looking for ways to make things healthier, maybe check out my keto spinach wraps for ideas on adapting recipes!

Estimated Nutritional Information

Just a little heads-up, these nutritional numbers are my best guess, okay? They can totally change depending on the exact brands of ingredients you use, especially the peanut butter! But generally, you’re looking at about 200 calories per cookie. That includes roughly 12g of fat, 20g of carbs, 4g of protein, and about 15g of sugar. So, enjoy them guilt-free, they’re totally worth it!

Share Your Buckeye Graham Cracker Creations!

Okay, now it’s YOUR turn! I absolutely LOVE hearing from you all and seeing what magic you create in your own kitchens. Did you make these Buckeye Graham Crackers? How did they turn out? Please, please, please leave a comment below and tell me all about it! If you snapped some photos, I’d be thrilled if you shared them on social media and tagged me – I love seeing your creations! And if you enjoyed this recipe, don’t forget to give it a star rating. You can learn more about my baking adventures over on my About Me page!

Print