Amazing DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween

Oh my gosh, are you ready for Halloween? It’s my absolute favorite time of year for getting creative in the kitchen, and if there’s one thing that screams Halloween without being too spooky, it’s gotta be these adorable DIY coffin sandwiches! Seriously, they are ridiculously easy to whip up, and the kids (and adults!) absolutely *adore* them. I remember one year, I made a whole platter of these for my niece’s Halloween party, and they were gone in like, five minutes flat. Everyone kept asking for the recipe, but it’s so simple, it’s practically magic! If you’re on the hunt for that perfect, fun, and totally doable Halloween party food, then look no further. Get ready to bring these fantastic DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween to life!

Why You’ll Love These DIY Coffin Sandwiches for Halloween

• Super Easy to Make: Seriously, you can whip these up in minutes!
• Kid-Approved Fun: The shape is just spooky enough, and they taste amazing.
• Perfect Party Pleasers: Great for school lunches, birthday parties, or just a fun Halloween treat!
• Totally Customizable: Easy to change up the fillings and decorations!

Gather Your Ingredients for DIY Coffin Sandwiches

Alright, let’s get down to business – grabbing what we need for these super cute coffin sandwiches! It’s all about keeping it simple, but oh-so-effective for that Halloween vibe. First up, you’ll need 2 slices of your favorite bread. White bread works great because it’s soft and easy to cut, but whole wheat is good too if that’s your jam. Then, we’ve got the classic combo: about 2 tablespoons of creamy peanut butter – or crunchy if you prefer! And to make things extra special, 1 tablespoon of your go-to jelly, like strawberry or grape. And for that extra Halloween sparkle? Grab about 1/4 teaspoon of fun Halloween-themed sprinkles! You know, the little orange, black, and purple ones. So easy, right?

Essential Equipment for Crafting DIY Coffin Sandwiches

Okay, so you don’t need a whole fancy kitchen setup for this one! All you really need is a good ol’ knife for spreading, a sturdy cutting board to protect your counters, and the star of the show – a coffin-shaped cookie cutter. That little guy is the secret sauce to getting those perfect spooky shapes!

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Halloween Coffin Sandwiches

Alrighty, let’s get these adorable little coffins assembled! It’s honestly so straightforward, you’ll be amazed. We’re going to go from plain ol’ bread to super spooky treats in just a few easy steps. Think of it as crafting delicious little edible tombstones that everyone will be dying to get their hands on. Seriously, seeing these come together is half the fun, and the payoff is huge when everyone oohs and aahs at your Halloween party table. We’ll make sure these DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween look amazing!

Cutting the Bread into Coffin Shapes

First things first, grab those bread slices and your trusty coffin cookie cutter. Place one slice of bread flat on your cutting board. Now, this is a pro tip from me: press down firmly and wiggle the cutter a little bit to get a really clean cut. You want that definite coffin edge, no doubt about it! Do this for both slices of bread. If you end up with a little bit of bread scrap around the edges, don’t toss them! You can always nibble on those while you work, or save them for breadcrumbs later.

Assembling Your DIY Coffin Sandwiches

Now for the yummy part – the filling! Take one of your perfectly cut coffin bread slices and spread that creamy peanut butter all over it, nice and even from edge to edge. Then, grab your jelly and do the same on the *other* coffin slice. Try not to let too much ooze out the sides – we want our coffins to look neat and tidy, right? Once both slices are prepped, carefully flip one over and place it right on top of the other, lining up those coffin edges as best as you can. Give it a gentle little press so everything sticks together.

Decorating Your Spooky Coffin Sandwiches

Time to add the final, spooky flair! This is where those Halloween sprinkles come in. You can just sprinkle them right on top of the sandwich, or if you want them to really stick, you can add a tiny bit more peanut butter or jelly to one side and then press the sprinkles into that. You could even use a little bit of edible marker to draw a spooky face or a little cross on the lid. It’s all about making your DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween totally unique and scream-worthy!

Tips for Perfect DIY Coffin Sandwiches

Okay, so you’ve got your coffin cutter and your fillings ready, but let’s talk about making these DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween absolute perfection! My biggest pet peeve is when the shapes don’t hold, or the filling squishes out the sides. So, here are my tried-and-true tips! If you don’t have a specific coffin cutter (oops!), don’t panic! You can totally get creative. Use a regular rectangular cutter and then just trim the top corners to give it a coffin-like point. Or, for really intricate shapes, you can even find templates online and carefully trace around them with a paring knife. Trust me, a little effort goes a long way! To stop that ooze-out, don’t go too heavy on the fillings, and spread them evenly, staying a little bit away from the very edge. For extra sturdiness, especially if you’re making these ahead for a party, you can add a tiny “glue” of peanut butter or cream cheese right in the center of the sandwich before pressing the halves together. It really helps keep everything in place! These little tricks ensure your Halloween party spread looks amazing, and you can check out even more Halloween party ideas for inspiration!

Creative Variations for Your Halloween Coffin Sandwiches

You know, the beauty of these DIY coffin sandwiches is how easy it is to get creative with them! Peanut butter and jelly is classic, but let’s think outside the box for your Halloween party. How about cream cheese with a swirl of raspberry jam for something a little different? Or if you’re going savory, a thin slice of ham and cheese works wonders too! And for decorations? Oh, the possibilities! My favorites are those little candy eyes you can buy – just stick two on top and suddenly you have a wide-eyed, spooky treat. You could also use an edible marker to draw on a little “RIP” or some spooky webs. Making these DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween super unique is half the fun, so go wild!

Serving and Storing Your DIY Coffin Sandwiches

Alright, serving up your spooky creations is almost as fun as making them! I love to arrange these DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween on a big platter, maybe nestled amongst some grape “eyeballs” or clementine “pumpkins” for a real Halloween spread that just screams fun. They look so cute! If you happen to have any leftovers (which is rare, trust me!), just wrap them up tightly in plastic wrap or pop them into an airtight container. They’ll stay pretty fresh at room temperature for a few hours, but for longer storage, the fridge is best. Just keep in mind the bread might get a tiny bit softer, but they’ll still taste delicious!

Frequently Asked Questions about DIY Coffin Sandwiches

Got questions about making these spooky little treats? I’ve got you! People always ask me about different ways to switch things up or if they can prep them ahead. Here are some of the most common ones I get about making our DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween absolutely perfect!

What are the best bread options for coffin sandwiches?

Honestly, softer breads work best because they’re way easier to cut with a cookie cutter. Think white bread, soft whole wheat, or even fluffy brioche. They hold their shape really well after cutting, which is exactly what you want for those crisp coffin edges!

How can I make coffin sandwiches for a nut-free party?

Oh, totally! If you need nut-free options, just swap the peanut butter for sunflower seed butter or a creamy cashew spread. Cream cheese with a little bit of jam or even some thin slices of turkey and cheese are fantastic alternatives too. Just make sure to check all your ingredients are nut-free!

Can I prepare these DIY coffin sandwiches ahead of time?

You absolutely can! My trick is to cut the bread shapes and mix the fillings separately the day before. Then, just before serving or packing them up, assemble them. If you assemble them too far ahead, the bread can get a little moist from the fillings, but if you wrap them tightly, they’re usually good to go for a few hours!

Estimated Nutritional Information for DIY Coffin Sandwiches

So, while these DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween are super fun and easy, it’s good to have a general idea of what you’re working with nutritionally! Keep in mind this is just an estimate, obviously, because all breads, peanut butters, jellies, and sprinkles are a little different. But generally, one sandwich made with standard white bread, peanut butter, and jelly comes in around 300 calories, with about 15g of fat, 8g of protein, 35g of carbs, and roughly 20g of sugar. Things can change a bit depending on what you’re filling them with, though!

Share Your Spooky Creations!

I just *love* seeing what you all come up with! If you make these DIY Coffin Sandwiches Halloween, please snap a pic and share it with me, or tell me in the comments below how they turned out. I’d love to see your spooky twists!

For more recipes follow me on PINTEREST

Print